I just finished 1 month of running Ubuntu Linux as my primary laptop (Lenovo Thinkpad T60) operating system. I shrunk my OEM Microsoft Windows XP partition down to 20GB via Ubuntu Gparted and installed Ubuntu. Here’s how it turned out:
Since it’s been a couple years since I ran Linux on the desktop, I forgot how many options you have in configuring your desktop with Linux distributions. I tried out KDE, XFCE, and Gnome via apt-get. It feels like they are all in perpetual beta - where I encounter problems, look up bugs, and Google for workarounds.
The hardware required a few tweaks that I found via Google research. Specifically, ATI doesn’t open-source their drivers and the driver that I got from them doesn’t work well at all. Thanks for nothing ATI. The problem with their driver wouldn’t allow me to suspend or hibernate the computer. Unrelated to ATI, after hibernation, all sound stops working. Also, if you start the computer with the external monitor disconnected you will not be able to connect it and use it - you need to actually reboot Linux to get the external monitor to work. I forgot that I rebooted my computer just before going to a presentation - that was an awkward experience.
My job required the use of Microsoft Excel - through plugins, compatibility with pivots, and external data access. Excel 2003 does not run through Wine and the commercial solutions to help with that were not very elegant if they worked at all. The front-runner, Crossover Office stated poor compatibility.
I decided to use VMware for my copy of Windows XP so that everything worked correctly. Using the VMware Converter tool it was a simple task. I can’t imagine it being any easier. I wound up after a few hours with a working VMware image of my original OEM Windows partition. Of course, because the ram, video, and cpu changed at the same time, I needed to re-activate Windows XP and Office 2003. It required that I call the hotline to do it - I was greeted by a very thick Indian accent from someone who gave me an activation key after lots of repeating the numbers. That was the toughest part - now I had Windows running under VMware. It is surprisingly fast for the applications that I need. The key, of course, is that the laptop has 3GB of physical memory, and thus I was able to dedicate enough memory to the virtual machine to keep it off the disk for most processing.
Unfortunately, moving files back and fourth from the VMware Windows to/from Linux was a pain in the butt.
Wireless networking in Gnome is unreliable and not straight-forward. It requires that I use my root pw (sudo) to unlock the keyring and reconnect to my wireless router every time I come home with my laptop. In addition I found that many hotel wireless networks were not found via the wireless networking widget in gnome and I would need to boot back into Windows to connect to them.
Connecting to Samba shares through Nautilus in Gnome or KDE’s Konqueror were unreliable compared to using Explorer in Windows - this actually surprised me considering how unhappy I was the the unreliability of Explorer - but I found myself using the VMware Windows copy to get files from Samba shares.
Looking back, I think I was expecting an experience like using my Apple computers at home when I tried this out. The Apple computers have a greatly simplified UI that doesn’t tempt you with changing colors, toolbars, etc. and a bash shell / posix environment that allows me to get my more technical work done throughout the day. I guess my best bet is really to install Ubuntu under VMware with MS-Windows as the host operating system, as much as it kills me to say it.
Of course, one would argue I should move to the Apple platform, but my corporate standard is currently Windows and Linux - and being part of IT, I need to use the platform that my users/clients here are using… otherwise I would be using an Apple.
Bookmark to: